The proposal to construct a new $32.1 million police station at 135 King Street dominated the later hours of Town Meeting, as officials and residents debated the necessity and cost of the project. Article 21 sought a new appropriation of $21.7 million to move forward with the police headquarters, which has seen significant cost escalations since its initial $10.4 million estimate in 2023.

Police Commander Gregory Lennon delivered a stark presentation on the deplorable conditions of the current Elm Street station, which was built in 1962. Lennon described evidence being processed in the staff breakroom, a lack of private space for victims, and non-compliant holding cells. The current environment hinders recruitment and officer well-being, Lennon stated, while Sergeant Patrick Reardon added that modern policing requires a facility that supports emotionally intelligent policing.

The project faced criticism from some residents regarding the process and transparency. Resident Leland Jenkins and others expressed concern over the tripling of the project's estimated cost. Member of the Capital Budget Committee Chrissy Francona expressed opposition based on the lack of transparency regarding total costs. Other residents, including Charlie DeSantis, suggested a repair and remain model to save money, though Committee Member Glenn Pratt noted that delaying the project would only lead to further cost increases due to inflation and deteriorating conditions.